Monday, August 1, 2016


hititandquit

Saturday, July 30, 2016

                            SHIP OF FOOLS


'As the Maine went, should go The Nation.' I published those words quite a few years ago. But see, the rusted hulk still floats, if just barely.
Donald Trump recently threw a press conference the other day. He said, inter alia:
       Why do I have to get involved with Putin? I have
      nothing to do with Putin. I’ve never spoken to him.
      I don’t know anything about him other than he will respect
      me. He doesn’t respect our president. And if it is
      Russia--which it’s probably not, nobody knows
      who it is--but if it is Russia, it’s really bad for another
       reason, because it shows how little respect they
       have for our country, when they would hack into
       a major party and get everything. But it would be
       interesting to see--I will tell you this--
       Russia, if you’re listening, I hope you’re able to
      find the 30,000 e-mails that are missing,
       I think you will be rewarded mightily by our press.
       Let’s see if that happens. That’ll be next.
       Yes, sir.
And all kind of heck followed.  Notably, Laurence Tribe, celebrated Constitutional scholar--perhaps even a bigger one than our President!--has opined that Donald Trump is guilty of treason. Treason, to my naïve eyes, is something defined in Article 3, §3 of the U.S. Constitution:
             Treason against the United States shall consist
             only in levying War against them, or in adhering to
             their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort.
              No person shall be convicted of Treason unless
              on the Testimony of two Witnesses to the
              same overt Act, or on Confession in open
              Court.
Professor Tribe takes exception. His monumental treatise, American Constitutional Law, is available on Amazon, new for $99.75--a considerable saving, since it lists at a cool $114--or, for those on a budget, Amazon will rent it for $34.92. An old whore, perhaps, but Lord love him, still a pricey one.  
Senator Claire McCaskill is more nuanced. She thinks Trump's crime is not treason, a capital offense, but a violation of the Logan Act, which carries a three-year max. Hey, after three years in the Big House, he could still fit in one year in the White House! The Logan Act, it may be recalled, was written by the same Federalist Congress that produced the Alien and Sedition Acts; and signed into law by John Adams, of whom Tom Paine said, 'His head is more filled with Kings and Queens and Jacks than a pack of cards.'
More central to the controversy were remarks made by Robby Mook (real name), Mrs. Clinton's campaign manager, intimating that Donald Trump has now been exposed as a cat's paw for Vladimir Putin. A valuable response to Mook, by Austin Bay, can be found at http://observer.com/2016/07/clinton-campaign-tries-to-deflect-damaging-content-with-trump-smear/
The Nation, too, objected to Mr. Mook. And their objection was entirely true to The Nation's long history  The Nation was founded in 1865, and in its early years, it took a dim view of the roistering Irish so too nearby the magazine's offices, of the childlike freedmen in the South, of the 'grossly ignorant laborers' of the Paris Commune.  From that day to today, when a Katha Pollitt* can write casually of Joe Sixpack, the dominant ethos of The Nation has remained the same: the δήμος is unsuited to self-rule. The line it has tended to take on certain phenomena, all related--the USSR; its successor, the Russian Federation; the Third International generally, and the CPUSA in particular--is best understood within the context of that disdain.


What was novel about Lenin? Marx had famously said that, 'Socialism is the work of the masses, or it is nothing.' He had serious reservations about the Second International, but his idea of the democratic dictatorship of the workers--'dictatorship' denoting the identity of the principal holders of political power, not prison camps and death squads--was best exemplified by the Paris Commune. Lenin had other ideas. He taught that industrial workers could never develop the proper consciousness on their own. They would have to be led by benefactors from the bourgeoisie. The Bolsheviks were a minority faction of the Russian Social Democratic Party, a Second International affiliate--in fact, essentially a cult centering on Ulyanov. Because at one meeting of the Social Democrats, in exile, his acolytes made up the majority, the pretense was born that the 'Bolsheviks' were a permanent majority. In January 1917, in Zurich, Lenin addressed a group, reaffirming his commitment to revolution in Russia, although he foresaw that it would not come in his or his auditors' lifetimes. Under the pressure of world war, the Romanov régime fell in February 1917. In April 1917, the Abwehr, the Kaiser's military intelligence, financed Lenin's return to St. Petersburg, with the expectation that Lenin could facilitate Russia's capitulation to Germany (He did accede to Germany's terms in March 1918, at Brest-Litovsk.) In November 1917, soldiers and sailors loyal to Lenin staged a coup (sometimes referred to as The Glorious October Revolution). Not long after, elections were held to the Duma. Lenin's partisans received a pathetic minority of the vote. Consequently, at the first seating of that body, its members were scattered at gunpoint. Civil war ensued. Pursuing  war remorselessly--utilizing famine,† mass reprisals against non-combatants, turning on allies who were past their usefulness--Lenin's faction prevailed. It's been well said that Leninism elevates opportunism to a principle.  A workers' revolution will be accomplished by peasants, a state based on workers' councils will abolish workers' councils, the state that will socialize property will embrace a New Economic Policy, the old liberal desiderata will be jettisoned. The Marxism of Lenin is a Marxism refined to pure instrumentality, cleansed completely of any ethical content. Its truer progenitor is Nechaev.  It is a methodology,  a means of seizing and holding power, which is what has made it so appealing to caudillos and strongmen around the world. Russian anarchists, in the earliest days of Lenin's rule (i.e., before they were killed) called the Bolsheviks 'the last gasp of the bourgeoisie.' A beamish optimism--but after all, these were anarchists. Working-class insurgencies against the rule of Leninist parties in various countries have never hesitated to identify their enemies as Red bourgeoisie.


Case in point: Below is a famous photo, taken by Vagn Hansen, dating from the Hungarian Revolution in 1956.

There is a line attributed to Lenin, one that C. L. R. James, for one, cited often: Every cook can govern. What Lenin in fact said was: ‘We know that an unskilled laborer or a cook cannot immediately get on with the job of state administration.’ The name of the young woman in the photo is Erika Szeles. She is fifteen years old in the photo, and until recently, had worked as an apprentice cook. Here, she has taken up arms in defense of the workers’ councils, first, against the enemies of her class, the MDP, a/k/a the Hungarian Working People’s Party [sic], and later, against the enemies of her country, the USSR. Not long after this photo was taken, the Red Army killed her.

What's radical about The Nation? Nothing I can see. It's a solidly bourgeois institution, with fine-tuned anti-democratic instincts. It--of course--is not kept afloat by newsstand sales, and this was true even before print became an endangered thing. It relies more on people who have lots of money but do not own a cat to bequeath it to. I can picture a Jack Abbott sitting in a maximum security facility reading a poem by Calvin Trillin: but I know social climbing when I see it. The appeal of Leninism to the Nationist sensibility has very little to do with the will to power that Leninism facilitates in some of the world's rougher precincts. Rather, it was the genius of Lenin to recognize the potential of an ascendant, but still weak, working class, capture it, and exploit it with fewer qualms than any Victorian capitalist (What the pink slip is to capitalist labor discipline, an unmarked grave is to its Leninist version); it was his folly to think the scam could last forever. For The Nation, the right kind of lower orders, manageable, and managed, lower orders are the New Man.


So: to the Trump bacchanal:
The Nation editorial on the controversy is called 'Against Neo-McCarthyism.' https://www.thenation.com/article/against-neo-mccarthyism/ We're off to a bad start.
Neo-anything, in current political chatter, tends to be thought of as obviously bad, no argument needed. But this is, worse yet, Neo-McCarthyism. And 'McCarthyism' is a fraught word. Invoking McCarthy is invoking--what? Austin Bay, cited above, also used the term McCarthyism, but he spelled out what he meant by it. Just as McCarthy waved lists of names, names not to be disclosed, Robby Mook appeared on television to cite the opinions of experts who could attest to the links between the Trump campaign and Russian intelligence: names not to be disclosed. Just as McCarthy had his 'conspiracy so immense,' Mrs. Clinton had her 'vast right-wing conspiracy.' And just as McCarthy condemned those he targeted for their 'disloyalty,' the Clinton campaign has condemned Donald Trump for his 'disloyalty.' Bay, in other words, offers specific parallels to specific failings in one specific antecessor.


For The Nation, 'McCarthyism' is the familiar haunted wood. Remarkably, the word 'McCarthyite' appears nowhere in the published editorial. For such restraint, credit where it's due. They write that


           
representative voices of the liberal establishment have joined with the forces of neoconservatism to engage in what can only be described as McCarthyist rhetoric


So: many heads got together, printed an article called 'Against Neo-McCarthyism,' and ended the very first sentence with the words, 'what can only be described as McCarthyist rhetoric.' No need to worry about 'the forces of neo-conservatism.' Those 'forces' are there for a quick effect and will not be the subject of any further, y'know, documentation.


They continue:


      
 This magazine, which has a long and proud history of standing up to the
 worst excesses of McCarthyism, repudiates this unwelcome echo of the past. Let us recall that McCarthyism impugned the loyalty of American citizens by accusing them of allegiance to the Soviet Union. This political defamation—often a joint undertaking of Congress and the media—suppressed democratic debate over alternative policies and ideas, and in the process destroyed lives by stigmatizing those whose views were deemed insufficiently loyal to Cold War–era orthodoxies. The overall effect was to poison, chill, and censor the political discourse of the nation.


Here, the tell is the repeated use of the word 'McCarthyism,' without a single reference to Joseph McCarthy himself. 'McCarthyism' is The Nation's term for opposition to the USSR internationally, and to the CPUSA domestically. Look again at Austin Bay's article. McCarthy waved a list of undisclosed names. 'McCarthyism' did not. Victor Navasky's major work is called, precisely, Naming Names. McCarthy talked about conspiracy. 'McCarthyism' did too, but much less so, and usually in cases where conspiracy was not a paranoid phantom, but--wait--real. McCarthy talked about 'disloyalty,' and so did 'McCarthyism: but there are loyalties, and loyalties.


The Nation's 'McCarthyism' embraces not just McCarthy himself, but the rest of the martyrology: HUAC, Truman, the Hollywood Ten, the Smith Act, Taft-Hartley, the Rosenbergs, Alger Hiss. Don't put the nickel in. 'What will we sing of in bad times? We will sing of bad times,' said Brecht. These guys will go on about the 'bad times' in any weather. And worse, they can't sing.


First, the thing with the names. What Mook did, referring to a troop of nameless experts had nothing to do with McCarthy. It's just somebody without an argument. The proper answer is not to wail about thetroubles Paul Robeson has seen, but to tell Mook to put up or shut up.


Second, the issue of conspiracy. In Russia, in the XIXth Century, most political agitation was illegal, and even more so after the killing of Aleksandr II. Some degree of clandestinity was necessary for anti-Tsarist groups. For Lenin, the conspiratorial model became its own end. A socialist could not be an ordinary worker alive to his own condition. For Lenin, only the professional revolutionary would do, organized into  an utterly discrete party, and subject to 'democratic centralism,' in practice, a euphemism for V. I. Lenin. This model survived any real need for it, whether after 1905, in 1917, or at any time after the coup d'état of that year. And that model of organization was imposed on any foreign group that wanted to align with the victorious Bolsheviks. What right-wing members of Congress might say about Communist conspiracies or the Third International/Cominform  may be casually dismissed, but anyone who has been involved in politics anywhere in the vicinity of a Leninist group will be familiar with the machinery of front groups, secret members, an unwavering--and quicksilver--party line.


And third, the question of loyalty. Famously, the Social Democratic parties in each of the belligerent states in Europe failed to oppose the war in 1914. Some dissident factions did take an anti-war position. Lenin, virtually alone, took a position of ‘revolutionary defeatism.’  He threw his support, for whatever that was worth, behind the Central Powers. If Germans were killing Russians in great numbers, that was fine with him. And as noted above, Imperial Germany's modest investment in Lenin ended up paying off handsomely: great territorial gains in the East, and the transformation of a two-front war into the full concentration of forces on France. For the foreign admirer of the 'Russian Revolution.' the USSR was humanity's bright future, the workers' homeland. What could be owed to the hellholes at home? And within Third International parties, subservience to the center's dictates was rigorously enforced. Even when a party, exceptionally, strayed, like the PCI, it was never all that far. American Communists, back in their heyday, were Twentieth Century Americanists, liberals in a hurry, premature anti-fascists. Uh-huh. Pete Seeger, never a Party member, during the period of the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, was singing about the warmonger Franklin D. Came the summer of 1941...there was a change in the set list.‡ Even in a time when Communist policies were least at odds with official U. S. policy, it's hard to imagine an Earl Browder, or even a senior editor at The Nation hoisting up a glass of something strong, and raising a toast, My country right or wrong. People may put their loyalties where they like, but they shouldn't complain if their loyalty to one thing is construed as a lesser loyalty to something antithetical.


But the Nation editorial wasn’t just about a ‘long and proud’ history.’ It addressed a current event, videlicet, Trump’s recent comments. Much of it is unexceptionable, and unexceptional. Russian involvement is now unproven, and the claims of espionage are certainly being used by representatives of the DNC/Clinton campaign--hardly distinguishable now, hardly distinguishable all along--to deflect attention from the substance of the hacked e-mails. And the editorial is quite correct to offer particular criticisms, welcome in any season, of Jeffrey Goldberg and Paul Krugman. But then...something goes awry. The Nation...becomes what it is.
Others, even some who loathe Trump, have  said that linking Trump to Putin is unfair to Trump. For The Nation, bringing Putin into it at all is unfair to Putin.  A few points:
--Redbaiting' is an ill-defined term. It's best looked at in operation. Let's stipulate first that merely to state an adversary's political affiliation is not usually an effective refutation of that adversary's argument. But take this case: some radical or visionary or one-who-dares-to-suggest-that, who happens also to be a member of the CPUSA, is criticized. It will not matter what arguments have been advanced against that visionary. If once the visionary's association with the CP is noted--accurately--Redbaiting has occurred, and every other argument, whatever its merit, is rendered invalid. The Nation has devoted itself over the years to ferreting out the intellectual delict of Redbaiting. The neologism contained in this editorial is Kremlin-baiting. Post-Soviet Russia has been described as Burkina Faso with nukes, as indeed the USSR was described in its day as Upper Volta with nukes. For The Nation, anything that even reminds them of the bad old days still produces a shiver, and many of the same courtesies afforded the old régime will be extended to its successor--especially when its leadership is so thoroughly vetted.
--The editorial says that the DNC e-mails reveal ‘several aborted attempts to tip the scales against [Sanders].’ Those weren’t attempts, and there was nothing aborted about them. There’s a pretty good chance that the nomination was stolen. Seeing as The Nation endorsed Sanders on its front cover--it seems so long ago now--they’re pretty blasé about it all. At the end of the day, comes their sage counsel, it is what it is.
--The editorial refers to ‘a reckless plank in the [proposed] Republican platform that pledged to further arm Kiev.’ Well: ‘Cet animal est très méchant./Quand on l’attaque, il se defend.’ If Ukraine is to want something so silly as independence, it will just have to learn from its own mistakes.
--The editorial refers derisively to ‘the narrative of a devious Russian cyber-attack.’ But cyber-hostilities, whether intelligence gathering or active sabotage, depend on subterfuge, and those governments involved in such activity are not necessarily the less savory ones. In the case of Russia, again, it’s not proven that it was behind the DNC hack.  But it’s a sure thing that its intelligence services are busy, busy on the Web, just as it’s a sure, and notorious thing that the walls between those services, the ‘civilian’ state, and the Mafiya are somewhat porous.
But finally it’s the special solicitude for Vladimir Putin’s good name that makes this editorial something that could be read on-air at RT.§ Just as DNC/Clinton spokesmen were eager to talk about anything but their e-mails, The Nation is eager to talk about anything but Putin, even if it benefits Trump. ‘No one wishes to defeat Donald Trump more than The Nation,’ they write This no-one-more-than-I formulation is an Obama standard, and it is unfailingly a lie. Trump will be given a pass|| if  the broader sweep of history, as they perceive it, demands it. What ought to trouble people most about Trump is his expressed admiration for ‘strong leaders’: For the ruling party in Beijing that has killed far more Chinese than Japan ever did; for Saddaam, whose Mukhabarat was trained by Putin’s KGB; and for Putin himself. Another photo from the Hungarian Revolution, taken by John Sadovy. It shows members of the AVH, Hungary’s Chekists, being held to account by members of the Hungarian working class.

It was a great missed historical opportunity when such scenes were not played out at Dzerzhinski Square. Russia, and the world, would have been better off. Putin was stationed in the DDR when the wall came down. If he knew that justice was being served to his colleagues back home, he would have been canny enough to seek refuge somewhere in the NATO zone, where he would be today, still less harm, trafficking women.
The editorial finishes with a ‘call[ ] on liberals...to undertake a serious conversation about U.S.-Russia relations’--oh, joy--and to reject the cheap [huh] Neo-McCarthyism [huh] that undermines these efforts’ [Which efforts?].’ And they bring the curtain down with: ‘But to adopt the pernicious language of McCarthyism is to turn our backs on the best traditions of our country in favor of the worst.’ The Trump/Putin controversy has not had to do with language as such, but with what may or may not be facts. What The Nation means by ‘the best traditions, they don’t say, and it doesn’t much bear thinking about. But the worst traditions? They’re clear enough. And no, chattel slavery, civil war, the bloody labor struggles of the late XIXth and early XXth, those don’t count. The worst of times came when the only true revolutionaries, the dead men on parole, comfortably ensconced within the capitalist order were required--or given the chance--to justify themselves publicly. Freedom is for the elect. The rest of us need to be reminded.


*At the foot of the online article can be found pictures of ‘Our Columnists’. The phrase, ‘rogues gallery.’ comes to mind, but that can’t be right; ‘rogue’ calls to  mind ‘charming.’ and--Anyway.Two of Our Columnists, Katha Pollitt and Eric Alterman were once members of JournoList. For anyone who missed it the first time, JournoList was a listserv that included, well, Katha Pollitt and Eric Alterman. Some of its e-mails were made public: shades of the DNC, shades of McCarthyism. Spokesmen for Journolist defended the group, asserting that it had done nothing wrong, and then dissolved the group. The trouble seemed to be that while nobody should ask for a forced ‘impartiality’ from someone who is openly an opinion journalist, the opinions should be arrived at honestly and honestly expressed. And JournoList’s internal communiqués strongly suggested that that ideal remained, alas, an ideal.
Spencer Ackerman, while not a Nation columnist was nevertheless the true soul of the group. Memorably, he wrote:
  • What is necessary is to raise the cost on the right of going after the left. In other words, find a rightwinger’s [sic] and smash it through a plate-glass window. Take a snapshot of the bleeding mess and send it out in a Christmas card to let the right know that it needs to live in a state of constant fear.
In a recent admiring profile of Mr. Ackerman, he is described as a ‘hardcore punk fan.’ Could I be mistaken in finding in Mr. Ackerman’s ‘bleeding mess’ an allusion to the Sex Pistols’ ‘throbbing squirm, gurgling bloody mess’?

Mr. Ackerman added, in my opinion superfluously, “Obviously I mean this rhetorically.’
†Let’s not forget Stephen Cohen, author of Why Bukharin Matters...or no. It had some other title. That was the punchline to a world’s-thinnest-books joke. There was another joke, from Russia in the ‘20’s.
-What do you call it when there’s food in the cities  and famine in the countryside?
-Trotskyism.
-What do you call it when there’s food in the countryside and famine in the cities?
-Right-wing Bukharinite deviationism.
-What do you call it when there’s food everywhere?
-Capitalist exploitation.
What do you call it when there’s universal famine?
-The correct Party line!
There’s room for Professor Cohen somewhere in that joke. It’ll just take the right audience.
‡Seeger, late in life, came to have second thoughts about some of his positions back then. But he can’t compare to Althusser’s indignant self-justification: he had already, in 1965, criticized Stalin.
§ I offer, for your consideration, the following video. And I ask: Why are these young men not on the editorial board of The Nation? The only possible explanation, as they say on MSNBC, is racism.


|| In a discussion of Trump and McCarthyism, how could they leave out his long association with Roy Cohn? It is an indicium of the rot so prevalent in the political/legal culture of New York City that a figure like Roy Cohn could, far from being a pariah, be a person of power and influence, and widely feared.
I would add that there is an odd resemblance between Roger Stone and Putin. From a distance, one could be mistaken for the other, and both like to display themselves shirtless.













r
Preview

No comments:

Post a Comment