PHILADELPHIA
During the period of Sendero Luminoso's greatest activity, its leader, Abimael Guzman, was in hiding. The Peruvian military, desperate to catch him, had only a few clues. Two of them were these: they knew that he had a dermatological condition treated with a certain ointment, and they knew the brand of cigarettes he smoked. Eventually, they zeroed in on one house that might be his hideout. They went through the garbage outside the house, and there they found cigarette butts of the right brand and empty tubes of the right ointment. Guzman was captured.
It seems likely that UBL's minders in Abbottabad were aware of Guzman's history and wanted to avoid his mistake. The compound there put out no garbage. Instead, everything was burned within the walls. But since people ordinarily don't burn their own garbage, this was itself a tell and was one of the things that led to UBL's death.
Both Guzman and UBL were attentive to the demands of effective concealment. But to a capable intelligence operation, even the most seemingly innocuous detail may be fatal. Secrets may be disclosed, despite anyone's best efforts, or so-so efforts, or what-care-I? laxity. It has been reported, in the context of some of the controversy surrounding Hillary Clinton, that her two most recent predecessors, George W. Bush's Secretaries of State, Colin Powell and Condoleezza Rice, used unsecured devices for official business. If so*, then, it was improper. But what, if anything, do they have to do with the Her of I'm With Her?
Hillary Clinton, immediately upon being confirmed as Secretary of State, set up a private server, entirely eschewing the governmental system in place. No innocent explanation for her choice is a serious possibility, and her successive justifications have, one after another, been exposed as deliberate--and transparent--falsehoods. Let that go. Hypothesize some non-duplicitous motivation. Setting up a private, non-secure server came with an implicit guarantee: that for the five years of her incumbency, no electronic communication that crossed the Secretary of State's desk would implicate national security. That implicit guarantee was a lie. It was a lie the day the server was arranged. It is a lie today. It was a lie when Barack Obama endorsed Mrs. Clinton, just as it was a lie the very first time he either received an e-mail from or sent one to her illegal server. It was a lie the day James Comey prattled on about what a 'reasonable prosecutor' would or wouldn't do†. It was a lie when Loretta Lynch‡ 'accepted' Comey's recommendation.
And this week, in Philadelphia, it will be a lie that will be hammered home, over and over and over.
* It would be surprising if there were not some carelessness on the part of Powell and Rice. But there is no claim that any such carelessness was systematic, nor even routine. Nor is there any suggestion that any lapses in security were motivated by a desire to conceal self-dealing. Further: the source of these reports is a little dubious. Functionaries of the State Department, required by court orders and Congressional subpœnas to produce records of Mrs. Clinton's electronic correspondence, have declared themselves unable to do so. It will be years before they can meet their legal obligations. The precise date is, who knows?, but it will be sometime after November 8 of this year. And yet: they had time to retrieve records from the turn of the century.
†The phrase 'reasonable prosecutor' is already something of an oxymoron. James Comey has a history as a hard-nosed, remorseless Federal prosecutor. He has proven something other when considering the powerful and connected. First, as has been widely noted, he has pretended that a criminal statute that requires proof only of gross negligence suddenly requires proof of specific intent. Second, it was pointed out to Comey in Congressional hearings that intent is generally determined by inference. But beyond that, what 'intent' could he possibly mean? Somebody who compromises security by forgetting to log off can, and should, be said to have acted without intent. But somebody who contracts with a private company to set up a private server, who pays a monthly fee for the service has fully intended to do so. Comey said that she did not intend to break the law. Interesting theory. A tax protestor who refuses to pay taxes and announces that refusal, stating some specific objection, e.g. military expenditures, has intended to break the law and is willing to accept the consequences. Somebody who tries to save $100,000 by filing fraudulent tax documents, in Comey's reading, has no interest in law-breaking, as such. It's not crime, just thrift, and so, presumably, laudable. He also argues that she did not intend to compromise national security. Maybe not. It's easy to imagine some such conversation;
IT Guy: You want this for your own use, no outside access, right?
HRC: Right. How good is the security?
--Depends what you want. If you--
--Okay, let's say I'm selling uranium.
--Uranium? Okay, whatever.
--It doesn't matter. I want to sell something. I want to do something. Who has access?
--Just you. But there are different levels of security. Tell me what you want.
--Say, I get a freedom-of-information request, what happens?
--Up to you.
--Meaning...?
--Produce it, or don't.
--Meaning?
--You can just delete it, if you want. Call it--
--Yoga?
--Yoga? Call it what you want. Just freedom of information?
--Lawsuits, Congress, whatever comes along.
--You have control. Just don't share your password.
--Understood. So, what are my options?
--I have two very good systems. They'll both do what you want. I should alert you, that one of them is pretty vulnerable to hacking by, like, Iran, China, the FSB, if any of that's a concern...but either one'll suit your needs.
--I'm thinking, I should go with the one that's less accessible to foreign intelligence. Don't you think...?
--Yeah. Yeah, I would. So we'll do the KGB-resistant one.
--Let's roll!
And surely, Mr. Comey's intuition is correct. In such a scenario, Mrs. Clinton would opt for the more secure set-up.
Jim Comey is spoken of in the most glowing terms by others in the Federal law-enforcement community. We are in good hands. We have been in good hands all along.
‡According to Richard Durbin, she is the Rosa Parks of our day.
No comments:
Post a Comment