Friday, January 20, 2017

                           TIME OF THE HERO

   John Lewis (D-Ga. 5th District) decided not to attend today's inauguration, and following his lead, more than sixty other members of Congress have also boycotted the event. Lewis , declaring the President-Elect 'illegitimate,' said that he would do what he had never done before, and refuse to legitimize--that seems to be the word--the incoming executive. In fact, he boycotted George W. Bush, in both 2001 and 2005. Whether that counts as one lie or two--who's keeping a tab? We're used to hearing easily discoverable lies from officials. But a little of Lewis' recent history:
--In 2008, he published an op-ed in the New York Times regarding the Presidential campaign. He was reminded of George Wallace. Not, he said, that his friend, John McCain was anything like Wallace, but...Oh yes! it was all just like George Wallace.
--When the ACA ('Obamacare') was under discussion, he led a group of black legislators down the front steps of the Capitol. The claim was then made that a group of Tea Party protestors had covered the legislators with spit and racial epithets. An offer of $100,000 was made for any footage that would verify the accusation. Despite the presence of several news crews, the $100,000 remains unclaimed.
--Last year, he denied that Bernie Sanders had ever taken part in the civil rights movement. In fact, Sanders was active in CORE and was arrested at rotests. But Hillary, now she was in the fiery heart of it. Well, in 1964, when a segregated Mississippi delegation was being seated at the Democratic National Convention, Hillary deserves none of the blame. She was a Goldwater Girl.

John Lewis is today described, even by people on the right, almost inevitably as a hero, an icon, inspiring. Truer to say: was a hero, is a hack. Lewis was prominent in the glory days of the civil rights movement and was, famously, severely beaten by cops at the Pettus Bridge. Honor to him for that. But...a good youth is no promise of a good age; almost the reverse. Ardor burns out, and purity encounters...things. We may recall Gilles de Rais, who was once the most devoted follower of Joan of Arc. Years later, he too ended up burned at the stake, but in his case , it was for diabolism and the murders of a few hundred children. A documentary about SNCC, if it fell into the where-are-they-now genre, might not be such a good idea. The most vivid characters would likely be Marion Barry, James Bevel, and H. Rap Brown.
Donald Trump, we learn, 'attacked' John Lewis. But certainly, he didn't strike first. Lewis, after all, called him 'illegitimate'--a pretty grave charge, and in effect, called him an FSB agent. In response, Trump said--fairly mildly, especially given that he is Donald Trump--that Lewis' home district has problems and that Lewis has a responsibility to attend to them. Neither claim should be particularly controversial. The ensuing outrage has had almost nothing to do with the specifics of Trump's criticisms, everything to do with the fact that anyone has dared to attack--John Lewis! George H W Bush was once bobbing in the ocean, desperate to avoid being captured--and eaten--by the Japanese; Bob Dole was once torn up by the guns of the Wehrmacht; John McCain was once tortured on a daily basis by Stalinist interrogators. In those circumstances, one wouldn't care to nitpick. Once they entered politics, and held or aspired to high office, they opened themselves up to hostile scrutiny. The famous exchange from Brecht's Life of Galileo Galilei:
         
              --Unhappy is the land that has no heroes.
              --Unhappy is the land that needs a hero.

Chatter about 'heroes' and 'icons' should have no place in our politics. What does any one person, or one life matter. The democratic answer is an austere one: nothing in particular.  And who are these 'inspiring' politicians? Inspiring to what, other than some nebulous sense of righteousness. Mood-altering drugs, many covered by insurance, would be preferable, and less necrotizing to the public discourse. And why would anybody think that an 'icon' is beyond criticism? John Lewis himself got elected to the House of Representatives by mounting a campaign of vilification against his once upon a time brother-in-struggle, Julian Bond, denouncing him as a druggie. His challenge to Bond was: I peed in a cup; where's yours? Such a line of attack is rawer than anything Trump's come up with, but it's not hard to imagine Trump saying it. If he did, though, it would be to amuse a crowd, and it would be received uproariously. With John Lewis, it was his whole campaign. If we want to know just how much immunity participation in the civil rights movement buys, John Lewis has given us the measure.  That was then , they say. Not long ago, John Lewis led a small group of legislators in a sit-in in the Capitol, in support of a gun-control bill. Amid all the recent invocations of Selma and MLK, it would be easy to forget that Lewis has a day job (and Trump was rude enough to mention it). Once, sit-ins faced certain arrest, and the real risk of violence, civilian and official: they aimed at overturning a social order. Today, legislators who can't get a bill passed--sometimes you just lose, sometimes you can't be bothered crafting something that gives you less than you wanted but can peel away sufficient votes from the other side--plop themselves down on the carpeting at heir place of employment. It's not law-making, bu the moral pretensions are unmistakable: workplace violins, if you will. Where there was once heroism, there's now only heroics. It's the difference between a Matthew Brady photograph and an iPhone video of Civil War re-enactors.

If I were President, I'd be inclined to skip out on the ceremonies myself, to find whatever big fun was on offer past the Beltway. So, to all our principled Representatives: enjoy your three-day weekend!

Sunday, January 15, 2017

                                        MOON SHOT

It's awards season: Golden Globes, a flurry of Presidential Medals of Freedom for some of our most prominent stars of the Silver Screen, even a medal bestowed by the Pentagon on the Commander-in -Chief. And now, in its solitary magnificence, there's this:


What did the outgoing Vice-President do, beyond just being there, to deserve such an honor? Here's a hint: A year ago, as part of his State of the Union Address, our outgoing President announced an end to cancer. Tom Price, the HHS Secretary-designee, has been called out by Marilyn Geewax, of NPR, because he 'refused to applaud' the POTUS. The criticism is quite unfair. Obama put Joe Biden in charge of ending the scourge of cancer. When Price is sworn in, well, come Friday at noon, what will be left for Price to do?