Todo MoDo
Some years back, the New York Times rolled out a peculiar online model. All its content would be freely available, except for its opinion writers, who were behind a paywall. It didn’t last, and James Taranto, of the Wall Street Journal, later described it as the Golden Age of Internet Journalism. So here, in Sunday’s Review section, we find Maureen Dowd--again!--holding forth on matters of general interest. Her column is called ‘The Alt Right Is All Wrong.’ http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/28/opinion/sunday/the-alt-right-is-all-wrong.html?_r=0True enough. But how would she know?
Mrs. Clinton’s alt-right speech was a thing eagerly anticipated. The alt right itself is an amorphous entity, not well known to most people, not well defined for anybody. That lack of definition and its novelty lend it a certain mystique. There is even some suspicion that it is of some intellectual interest. Here the name that comes up is Milo Yiannopoulos a/k/a Nero a/k/a the Dangerous Faggot, but usually just Milo. Milo has been described as ‘vacuous and sinister.’ Neither term quite fits--it would be a hard combination for anyone to live up to--but you can see what was meant. What he is is a brilliantly efficient provocateur. Mrs. Clinton cited two articles by Milo, although she didn’t mention his name. Naturally, he was delighted. He urged people to go read the articles for themselves. Should they do so., they will find pearls like this: ‘As far as I can tell, most women are hysterical, hypercritical harpies towards their boyfriends and husbands the vast majority of the time. Man am I relieved to be a fag right now.’ In an article published since ‘the Reno speech,’ he has revisited his claims regarding the Pill, but he now says that the washing machine has also had a ruinous effect on the women of today. In the middle of his arguments, he throws in:
No offense!
[The man on the right is Milo. In this clearly Photoshopped image, the man on the left only appears to be offering submission to Milo. In the original photo, he was doing so to a small group of Saudi notables.]
Milo is the co-author of a taxonomy of the alt right, which, while it casts too kindly an eye on its subject, is probably the best starting point for anyone interested in the subject. According to Milo, the hallmark of the alt right is its sheer intelligence--and ohmyGod, is he wrong. He also says that the typical alt righter is a 17-year-old. But no, they post videos, and they’re long past 17, though, in some respects, you wouldn’t know it. The alt right is a pretty fetid atmosphere: you can’t linger there. What could be mistaken for intelligence, and where they are not ‘all wrong,’ is their complete rejection of various pieties. It’s when they start offering their own solutions everything goes haywire.
Dowd writes that Mrs. Clinton ‘delivered a coup de grâce so devastating that commentators predicted it will be known simply as the Reno speech.’ A ‘senior citizen,’ she reports with some delicacy, pumped his fist and said that his candidate had kicked ass. (Count on the Times for being fit to print, if not necessarily news.) Those ‘commentators’: they really do comment, don’t they? And this coup de grâce--the devastating variety--is only the latest final defeat Trump has suffered since the day he announced. And a ratification from a ‘senior citizen’ isn’t really just what’s wanted, when the word ‘geriatric’ is never far away.
There is a certain absence of self-awareness at work. Should Hillary Clinton, of all people, be talking about the Justice Department? She condemns Trump for birtherism, although he was a late arrival at the party she threw. Dowd says that Trump ‘has no fixed ideology of his own except winning.’ The ‘Reno speech’--and why not go full Obama and give it some sonorous title?--makes clear that Donald Trump is Putin’s agent, a theme that Robbie Mook has been hammering. Should Hillary Clinton be talking about Russia? The absolute high point of her dealings with that limited democracy was the ‘reset’ button, a débâcle that she now describes, if she do say so herself, as ‘a brilliant stroke.’ Recall that the premise of that brilliant stroke was that any strains between the United States and the Russian Federation had nothing to do with the malice of Vladimir Putin. It was just this war and that lying son of a bitch Bush. She complained about Trump’s paranoia, even as her penchant for secrecy could yet land her in prison. She talked about Trump’s conspiracy-mongering. But if she ends up in Bartlett’s with only one quote, it will almost certainly include the word ‘conspiracy.’ This is a woman who has several times expressed a burning curiosity about Area 51 and who has spoken with the shade of Eleanor Roosevelt. (It was thought to be reassuring that her conversations with the dead were not anything kooky like seances, but brisk, businesslike brainstorming sessions.) She noted, accurately, that David Duke had endorsed Trump. But two things should be noted about that endorsement. First, after Trump repudiated it, Duke did not withdraw it. Second, Duke has also endorsed Occupy Wall Street. Duke is an opportunist, and his endorsements say a good deal about him, next to nothing about their ‘beneficiaries.’ She said that there was no precedent for a major party running on ‘racial resentment.’ And yet: a threadbare Republican talking point it may be, but the Democratic Party, and only the Democratic Party, has had an identity of interest with such phenomena as chattel slavery, Jim Crow, and the Klan.
A heckler, who identified himself as proudly alt right, was ejected when he yelled ‘Pepe!’, a reference to a cartoon frog, of indeterminate immigration status, beloved of the alt right.. Mrs. Clinton went on to explain that this group has seized control of the Republican Party.
In ‘the Reno speech,’ Mrs. Clinton said, ‘Racists now call themselves racialists, white supremacists now call themselves white nationalists, the paranoid fringe now calls itself alt right, but the hate burns bright
Here’s the trouble. If people start calling themselves ‘racialists, for example, they do so for some reason. Their views may in fact be something new, or the novelty may be something only they can see. Or the new term may only be a rebranding of the exact same old. If this new movement is to be discussed, the novelty must be accounted for, even if only by demonstrating its real nonexistence. When an alt right speech was announced, the prospect was offered of Hillary Clinton talking on, yes, in the same sentence, ideas. Hillary Clinton would be saying something, which even if wrong, would be, yes, in the same sentence, interesting. In the event, it was, as Milo noted, just name-calling.
If Donald Trump can restrict himself to reading from his own teleprompter for three days running, it’s news. But according to Mrs. Clinton, he has become the passive tool of a small army of Caligaris.
Does ‘the paranoid fringe’ call itself the alt right? Does she really think that there’s a ‘the paranoid fringe’? There’s a lot of...idiosyncrasy out there, and some of it might be found in the audience in attendance at ‘the Reno speech.’ even among the ‘commentators’ who dubbed it ‘the Reno speech,’ even behind the microphone, even on the op-ed page of the Times.
The late Alexander Cockburn used to produce charts linking bad political actors, as, from a different point along the spectrum, does David Horowitz today. We might even, were we to stoop to Mrs. Clinton’s level, say that ‘the Reno speech’ calls to mind the witches’ brews served up by the prosecutors at The Stalinist show trials.
Let me close with something that will probably be meaningful only to those of us who are passionate about couture. If that whole Area 51 thing pans out as Mrs. Clinton seems to expect, They will probably have room for a previously Earth-bound passenger or two. Hillary Clinton has shown in some of her fashion choices that she’s booked up and bound to go.

No comments:
Post a Comment