Kamala, the Amphibrach
- Much has been made of Harris’ offputting personality. We shouldn’t be too quick to think she’s nasty at her core. Kamala is a cop, they say, and her work experiencAe has been as a prosecutor. Her manner in Senate hearings is evidence of déformation professionnelle. Prosecutors, from a perch of immunity, are free to stick it to you--and will relish letting you know that. Whether they will, when they will, how badly, with whatever, if any, justification, all that is, in legal parlance, within the prosecutor’s discretion; in reality, at the prosecutor’s whim. What makes Harris’ Senate performances so ludicrous (apart from the gross transparency of her ambition) is this: The person who sits across from the sneering prosecutor is always vulnerable. The person who sits across from the Senate blowhard... might be anybody, might even be somebody free.
- When Harris announced her Presidential run, I was looking forward to it. Harris is the child of two highly accomplished parents. Her background is one of privilege. Her accession to political office, thanks to skillful networking, was a smooth glide. The advance from local to statewide office was easy-peasy. Getting elected to the U.S. Senate as a Democrat is, in California, something you can do in your sleep. Oddly, though, the national figure that has emerged, on whom Fortune has so smiled, is a singularly unpleasant presence.
- It was said, in 2012, that a number of strong Republican candidates chose not to run for President because doing so would be signing up for a billion dollars’ worth of abuse thrown at one head. In 2016, the combined force of a billion and a half dollars, the Republican party, the Democratic party, the dominant ideology, the media, show biz, the political police apparatus--they all had the bad luck to bump into Donald Trump. It didn’t go well for them. This year, Trump has lots of money to play with, but that won’t be what matters.
What was true before Harris crashed and burned and abandoned her Presidential campaign remains so today: she don’t know what trouble is.
4. Harris sheds an interesting light on the Obama birther hoopla. That was always nonsense, spiraling into ever more baroque absurdities. What it never was was racist.
Think of black people who have run for President (Chisholm, Booker, Deval Patrick) or even who have been touted as candidates (Colin Powell, Oprah Winfrey). Think even of fringier candidates, like Eldridge Cleaver or Alan Keyes. Nobody ever hinted that they were foreign born. There are many slurs and negative stereotypes that have been thrown at black people. Being from some other country isn’t among them.
What happened, then, with Obama? A more basic question: what is the difference between Barack Obama and Chauncey Gardiner? Answer: Chauncey Gardiner was reared by a black woman, in a black city. When Obama first emerged as a national figure, he was usually described as bi-racial. And that bi- element was his basic shtick: he could bring everybody together because, why, he himself had--you know the thing. Obama was never black, as the term has been understood in an American context. How best to categorize him? Bi-racial is adequate, but it’s an unstable term, and many people consider it a dodge. Black-ish fits, but it doesn’t fit him, only other people’s framing of him. African-American? When John Kerry was running for President--look it up: this really happened--Teresa Heinz (née Maria Teresa Thierstein Simões-Ferreira), born in Mozambique, made a timid effort to present herself as African-American. It went nowhere. It was technically accurate in her case, but that isn’t what the term is understood to mean. Obama is African-American only in Teresa Heinz’s sense, and his claim is far more tenuous. Obama may look black--the pompous thing is to speak of his “phenotype”--but if that proves anything, then Hello, Bob Barr! Welcome, Keith Jarrett! and Bye-bye, Walter Francis White. Until his late adolescence, Obama was culturally as white as anyone in the country. His present speech and mannerisms are late acquisitions--cultural appropriation, if you like that term.
It apparently wasn’t until the 2010 Census that Obama called himself black (He has proven himself over time as a proficient scholar of what he can get away with.) That a Barack Obama could ever be considered anything other than white is a strong argument that there is an enduring racial caste system in the country.
An Obama classic: He’s in the White House, putting Benjamin Netanyahu in his place. Here is Obama, son of two Harvard graduate students, one a high government official, one a doctoral level anthropologist doing field work. He is raised first in the household of a very wealthy oil executive, then in the household of a bank vice-president. He attends the toniest prep school in one state, goes to a pricey college in a second state, finishes at an Ivy League school in a third state, graduates from another Ivy League law school in a fourth state. In 2009, he departs his mansion in one of the richest zip codes in the country and takes up residence in the White House. And now to impress upon Netanyahu the gritty realities he’s lived through, he says, “I’m the African-American son of a single mother.” Who’d’ve guessed? That’s Bigger Thomas sitting at the Resolute desk!
But before Obama started passing himself off as black, he passed himself off as...other, as exotic. Really, there is nothing interesting about Obama. Occasionally, you’ll find an article about Dearborn, MI, with its sizable Arab-American population. There, people with roots in the Middle East become perfect Mid-Westerners. Haroun goes by Harry, Mahmoud by Mac. With Obama, the process is reversed. He grew up as Barry, as familiar a name as you could ask for, nothing worth a second’s thought (like its bearer). Then, in late adolescence, early adulthood, somewhere in there, Barry becomes Barack, although it appears he didn’t settle on a pronunciation or even a spelling right away. He’s eaten dog meat. It wasn’t good, but it has real value: he has eaten it--and you haven’t. His name is...Barack? For you, a hurdle,for him, an edge. If you should mispronounce it, he can, graciously, let it go, honing the condescension that is his signature style. It is around th same time that he started playing up his largely imaginary ties to Kenya. He has exploited this cultivated exoticism, this studied otherness--but only after his first attempt at electoral politics, when he posed as a representative of the community, a pose the community swatted away with contempt. Thereafter, he became the Messiah, the Lightworker, the One, who has brought us out of the darkness and into the light, the supernal Presence. In 2008, he was not initially the preferred candidate among black voters. He pitched his campaign first at upscale whites. He won the Iowa caucuses--questionably--and only then became, arguably, a non-white politician. The Visitor from, almost, another land, and certainly from a whole other plane, posturing has served him well. When it starts to cut against him--and birtherism, ill-reasoned though it is, is an instance of such cutting against--Obama’s acolytes have accusations--notably, racism--lying comfortably to hand.
Some silly arguments have been made about Article II, Section 1 as it pertains to Harris’ parents. But nobody has alleged that she was born elsewhere. Despite the fact that she has two foreign-born parents (to Obama’s one) and spent her high school years in a foreign country (to Obama’s early childhood in a foreign country), she is nowhere regarded as alien. Simple difference from Obama: she never wrapped herself in exoticism, and so never had that price to pay.
Postscript
One of Harris’ ancestors was a major slaveholder in Jamaica named Hamilton Brown. Bob Marley’s “Mr. Brown” might make a nice campaign song for Hamilton's newly famous descendant.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i3nsefsAk2o
No comments:
Post a Comment