After the massacre at the Pulse nightclub in Orlando, the President spoke, sort of, to the issue. Let me lay out an assumption. Presidents may be expected to say something about major events--or maybe not--but there's no reason for their comments to be definitive of anything. Think of a few earlier Presidents. Washington's Farewell is remembered, but it was a farewell, not a comment on some event of the day. The Gettysburg Address was given at the dedication of a cemetery, as part of a formal ceremony. Lincoln gave no great consolatory speeches after military defeats at Bull Run or Fredericksburg. And after Antietam or Gettysburg or Vicksburg, he did not announce what his military had done on his behalf. Inaugural addresses are ceremonial, and rarely memorable--Lincoln's are two very rare exceptions. What Washington understood about the office, despite the urging of many of his contemporaries, is that the President is essentially just another OPM number, and he understood this before OPM numbers existed. To depend on the Article II power for sustenance, moral, intellectual, or spiritual is violative of the republican spirit.
So: Daesh, a/k/a ISIS, a/k/a the Islamic State, has a military strategy, which it calls 'the management of savagery.' One part is the familiar military business of taking and holding territory. The Daesh variant is this: the kuffar are destroyed, either by being put to flight, killed, forcibly converted, or made sex slaves; all non-Muhammadan structures are destroyed (some ancient artifacts are stolen and sold on the black market); and public atrocities are used to keep the newly subject populations in line.
A second part is the organized military attack on civilians, the recent killings in Brussels and Paris being examples. These are not a Daesh innovation. The Mumbai attack was a notable precursor. What is new in Daesh's approach is that they are striving to make these frequent. A third part is what we saw in Orlando. To use terms like 'home-grown,' 'self-radicalized,' or 'lone wolf' is to miss the point. It is a major point of Daesh strategy to encourage its followers online, to advise them on targets (They have recently recommended hospitals and amusement parks as good options.)and tactics--for instance, they post bomb-making instructions. And anyone who acts on Daesh's exhortations can be sure of great posthumous celebration. Consider, too, the simple efficiency of something like the Orlando massacre. Daesh could kill 50 civilians at the price of a single 'lion.' To kill 50 American Marines, by contrast, would cost Daesh hundreds of fighters. Further, attacks on civilians have consequences beyond the cost in lives. Richard Reid failed to set off a bomb, but 15 years later, people are still walking through security checkpoints in bare feet.
So: after the massacre, President Obama had some public comments. Now, the President never talks about Daesh, nor does he call it ISIS or the Islamic State. It has always been, for him, ISIL. The 'L' is for the Levant and who can say, just, where that is. What must not be mentioned is...Syria. There is some history there. In 2009, Obama's first Secretary of State lauded Young Assad as a 'reformer.' Soon after, the reforms took a turn for the worse. The dead are now around 400,000, and about half the population has been displaced. Obama's responses to events in Syria are well known, but worth a recap. If the regime there started 'moving around or deploying chemical weapons,' he said--actually he said 'a whole bunch of chemical weapon,' but same difference--'that would change [his]
calculus.' * An Obama utterance is a target-rich environment. Let's wade in. Notice, first, that when he said this, the death toll in Syria was less than half what it is today. So while things there have grown worse beyond most expectations, here, oddly, there is...complete stasis. Having laid down a marker, and Assad having crossed that 'red line,' Obama tossed it over to Congress. That would be an unsurprising course of action, for other Presidents. It's a little out of character for him, though. We should consider the Libyan precedent. Our kinetic military action there had, it seems, nothing to do with an actual war. And its aims extended only to a modest R2P. Regime change was not contemplated, Obama said, although his Secretary of State whooped, 'We came, we saw, he died.' Now, if Mu'ammar Qadhdhaafi is to be mourned, somebody other than me will have to do it. But there's a larger lesson to be learned from his death. After the fall of Saddaam, Qadhdhaafi surrendered his nuclear weapons program and made, essentially, a plea deal. The United States did not have to accept any such plea, but once it did, Qadhdhaafi was neither a friend nor an ally, but he had a right to consider himself under at least a little guarantee. He guessed wrong. He cut a deal, he gave up his weapons, and the Americans saw to it that his death was a violent one. Other actors elsewhere in the world have drawn their own conclusions. (Ukraine, too, gave up its nuclear arsenal in exchange for guarantees from both Russia and the United States. Non-proliferation, it appears, is for suckers.)But the most surprising part of the Libyan adventure was something else. Congress was never approached for its approval, which fact demonstrates that asking its approval regarding Syria was just blame-shifting. Instead, the justification was offered that the kinetic military action had been authorized by the Arab League.
'The United States and the Russian Federation...taking into account the
commitment of Ukraine to eliminate all nuclear weapons from its
territory...reaffirm their commitment to Ukraine to respect the
independence and sovereignty and the existing borders of Ukraine...
and reaffirm their obligation to refrain from the threat or use of force
against the territorial integrity or political independence of Ukraine,'
from the Budapest Memorandum on Security Assurances,
Dec. 5, 1994
And the red lines? It helps to understand that nothing Obama says is true. It's not that he always lies. He does lie, frequently and reflexively. But much of what he says is sincerely believed: shibboleths, misinformation, frayed logic, the prejudices of our betters. And much of it, what the press usually describes as 'soaring rhetoric,' is just pablum. It is so not there as not to register on any true-false spectrum. It's just gas. So now, he said, he had never drawn any red lines. The world had drawn red lines.To be clear: he did not say, I was not alone in drawing red lines. Rather, he hadn't done it, he claimed. Sometimes, Obama's untruths are so blatant that it's not easy to decide if they're better classed as lying or raving. The world, for its part, could not be located, to either confirm or deny. And he added that it was the Congress that had drawn red lines.It was an important addition: nobody should be left in any doubt about how seriously America's threats should be taken.
Anyways, it's ISIL, not ISIS, never ISIS. ISIL, ISIL, ISIL...
But not always. The killer at the Pulse nightclub pledged his allegiance to, well, not ISIL exactly, but personally to Ibraahiim Awaad Ibraahiim Ali Muhammad al-Badri as-Saamaraa'i, better known as Abu Bakr al-Baghdaadi. The Justice Department released a transcript of the killer's calls to the police from inside Pulse. The name of al-Baghdaadi was redacted in the initial release, restored only after great public pressure, and ridicule. The President has denounced homophobia in connection with the massacre. The Attorney General, asked what the killer had said regarding his victims' sexual orientation, answered, 'He didn't go into that.' She added that he was 'hateful.' She has since declared that his motivation may never be known. (By contrast, the people who attacked the American diplomatic mission in Benghazi have not even been identified. But their motivation was known, and announced, early and often. They were outraged by a 'hateful' video, which was made, funnily enough, by a Copt who had escaped Egypt, where those who slander the Prophet of Islam--and the future must not belong to them--would face serious legal consequences. He had escaped Egypt and arrived in a land of free speech and religious liberty, but at the wrong time: less than two months before a Presidential election.)
The Orlando massacre was still only hours old. This would be another of those teachable moments that have so abounded in this Age of Obama. ISIL had struck, and--but no, that's not what he came to say. The last President offered the indefensibly vague Global War On Terror--as if Navy SEALs were in Bilbao shooting it out with the ETA. But as the current President has said, 'The shadow of crisis has passed.' We now have 'man-caused disasters'--a bus driver nodding off at the wheel?--and 'violent extremism'--people disrupting a Trump rally?--and, more cryptically, 'overseas contingency operations' (which seems to mean just killing people).
The President spoke, and he identified the culprit: it was Hate. That's not good news. If the enemy were Daesh, we could bomb Raqqa, trace Daesh agents and kill them--we could fight Daesh. But how does this one man fight--and defeat--Hate? No wonder he assigned Joe Biden to the eradication of cancer by year's end: that was, in comparative terms, a piece of cake.
He said more, though. He had i.d.ed Hate because any phrase involving the word Islam was unavailable to him. He derided 'magic words.' But isn't it magical thinking to imagine that labelling something magic refutes it? What could calling something by a different name accomplish, he demanded. Some history: Obama first came to national prominence when he addressed the Democratic National Convention in 2004. The best that may be said about that speech was that it was a fair foretaste of the oatmeal to come. But his live audience was electrified. It must be noted, though, that this was a crowd that could watch John Kerry come out on stage and 'report for duty'--and nobody laughed. In 2008, Senator Clinton's campaign hammered the theme that all her opponent had done was give a speech. Obama didn't really deny it--what else was there?--but he travelled the country repeating, in words he appropriated without attribution from another politician's speechwriter, 'Don't tell me words don't matter!' Okay, I won't. Turns out that's his job, and for once, he's on it. What, then, might a different terminology accomplish? Try this: to address a problem is not to resolve it; but unless it is addressed, it can't be resolved; and it can't be addressed unless it's first identified. To me, it seems straightforward...
And he went on, as he does. He complained of yappin'. In 2008, the Rev. Jesse Jackson was caught on tape saying that he wanted to cut then candidate Obama's nuts out, for 'talking down to black people.' The complaint seems needlessly divisive: Obama condescends to everybody. But when the g's start to fallin away, it's something special. It means he's gone to fetch a ladder, for a better angle to pee on you. After Jared Loughner shot six people dead in Tucson, most notably including a nine-year-old girl, Obama gave a speech, more of that 'soaring rhetoric,' in which he valorized civility and stressed the importance of listening to each other. Ah, well. They grow up so fast, don't they?
And all this yappin', he said, would not prevent 'folks' in government from 'doin' their jobs.' Let's linger on 'folks' for a bit. He won't mind. Meeting with Netanyahu not long ago, he said,
Bibi, you have to understand something. I’m the African-American
son of a single mother, and I live here, in this house. I live in the
White House. I managed to get elected president of the
United States. You think I don't understand what you're
talking about, but I do.
Here, I'm afraid, our President must settle on one thing. If he, the child of two Harvard Ph.D.'s, raised first in the household of an oil company executive, then in that of a bank's vice-president, the product of prep school and Ivy League, has decided to present himself as Bigger Thomas, so be it. But he can't at the same time keep tellin' folks that he's Buck Owens.
And as to 'folks...doin' their jobs?' People are entitled to ask, How well? And also, Obama likes to use the phrase 'doing (or doin') my job' to foreclose legitimate debate on policy matters.
The yappin' and the magic words are now well behind us. Let's get back to Hate. How will we know it? If a kidnapper sends a finger or an ear with the ransom demand, is that hate? When Abu Mus'ab az-Zarqaawi, 'the Shaikh of the Slaughterers,' bombed Shi'a religious processions was that hate,
or the coldest of calculations? Himmler praised his SS subordinates for their devotion to duty in carrying out the distasteful business of exterminating a race. A mosque in Orlando back in April featured a presentation by Dr, Farrokh Sekaleshfar, who says that for gays, 'Death is the sentence, ' adding, 'We have to have compassion for people.'*** To call that hate would, it seems be the very opposite of the truth. Concededly, Hate seldom announces itself, but even when it does...For instance, Debbie Wasserman-Schultz's predecessor as chair of the DNC, Dr. Howard Dean, has said in that role, 'I hate Republicans and everything they stand for.' Has the President designated a drone with Dr. Dean's name on it? or would that be, as I believe, a waste of good ordinance?
Violent extremism, man-caused disaster, and certainly Obama's daily target in 2008, 'cynicism,' have, it seems, met their match and been overcome. It's to be Hate. John Lewis, (Ga., 5th CD) recently sent out a tweet, 'Hate is too heavy a burden to bear.' This being a tweet, there was no room to spell out what Hate was, exactly. Senator Elizabeth Warren has done better. She was recently photographed holding a rainbow sign, with the words, 'Disarm Hate,' inscribed. The party convention needn't worry about working out a platform. That picture is pretty much it: an ostentatious LGBT outreach, gun control, a strong disapproval of Hate, implicitly an embrace of identity politics.****
As a response to Orlando, it is something less. How homophobic was the massacre? Neither Daesh nor Umar Mateen played up that angle. For them, anyone killed by one of their 'lions,' their 'knights,' is a blessing. Certainly, Daesh would regard a gay nightclub as depraved. They would regard any nightclub the same way, or the glimpse of a female ankle. Mateen cased Disney World, but the lion was scared off by the security there. If Mateen had shot up the Emanuel A. M. E. Church, Daesh might have been even more delighted. To the extent that the massacre creates pro-LGBT sympathy, it's a good thing. But the 'management of savagery' should not be equated with some supposed Christian bigotry. It is simply untrue that gays cannot be believing Christians, and it is a pretty sure thing that some of the dead were both those things. When a Muslim acting on behalf of a Muslim organization that destroys every Christian it can find kills scores of Christians, it should not be pinned on Christian intolerance.
Gun control, similarly, is not an easy fit for this story. It can be argued that you won't need an M60 to hunt quail, and as far as that goes, fair enough. But why 'disarm' Hate? If Hate is that hateful, why mention guns? Hate shouldn't have blunt objects, broken glass, piano wire. Flammable liquids have killed quite a few people at crowded night spots. Daesh, in fact, has taken a special pleasure in pre-industrial means of killing: fire, drowning, decapitation, crucifixion, throwing from heights. Disarming this Hate will need to be pretty comprehensive.
In the past couple of months, just about every time I've been to the library, I've seen an issue of Esquire with Donald Trump on the cover and the words, Hater In Chief. The Clinton campaign not long ago rolled out the--maladroit--slogan, Love Trumps Hate. Hate means..whatever it needs to mean. Hate is the Republican Party, plus any convenient, disfavored group. The Pulse massacre may be mined for its usefulness. There should be no distractions for President Fawlty, as he polishes his legacy and admonishes everybody not to mention the war.
______________________________________________________
Then there's love. Love came into its own as a political term of art in connection with the issue of gay marriage/marriage equality/SSM. After Obergefell against Hodges was decided, the slogan was broadcast, Love Wins. The phrase appears nowhere in the opinion by Anthony Kennedy, but it's consistent with the spirit of the opinion. Huh. The same result might have been reached with a rather different reasoning (or rather, with some reasoning). Civil marriage is not a sacrament. States issue marriage licenses, just as they issue drivers' licenses. If you've ever witnessed a civil marriage ceremony, you'll know what the word 'deflated' means. The lines at the DMV are longer, and the road test is more stringent than anything required for a marriage license. (On the other hand, if you want a picture of the wedding, you'll have to bring your own camera.) Kennedy might have considered civil marriage as a fairly routine ministerial function and found the sex of the applicants an inadequate basis for refusing to issue a license. What! and give up a chance to pontificate? Habituated to a deference repugnant to democratic spirit, he publishes pages of tripe. 'Marriage responds to the universal fear that a lonely person might call out only to find no one there.' Never mind the absence of an editor. Is he completely unaware that one can be alone, in any company? Disastrously, the opinion opens with
these words: 'The Constitution promises liberty to all within its reach.' The only way to try to make sense of such a sequence of words is to say, It does no such thing. This opinion was written at a premises minded by heavily armed security and adorned with images of a blindfolded woman brandishing a naked sword and an eagle clutching weapons of war. You may speak of liberty there, but speak low, and don't push your luck. And love, well, whereof one cannot speak...Above is a photo of Mr. Justice Kennedy. Here is a representation of Cupid and Psyche. Between Cupid and Kennedy, I see no resemblance. True, Kennedy is, like Paul McCartney's grandfather, very clean. And if I close my eyes, I can imagine Kennedy at Psyche's bedside, hovering. But no, it's not working for me.
Sex and love and marriage are three distinct things. They may come together into a unity, and that's an ideal, but the ideal isn't what we walk through every day. People are often pretty happy with just two of the three, and each, unaccompanied, has its partisans. Historically, romantic love was thought to be inconsistent with marriage, and sexual contact not an essential element of it. Yet Secretary Clinton talks often about people being allowed to love who they want. And when was that forbidden (and how would anyone forbid it)? Michelle Obama just sent out a fund-raising pitch, which referred to the 'one year since the Supreme Court ruled that every American has the right to marry the person they love.' Did they, now? And does Princeton not have a Freshman English requirement, or is this a sly shoutout to the polyamory community?
The integration of gay people into American life traces back to Stonewall, and the immediate post-,Stonewall years had no thought of marriage, and love, as such, was beyond the reach of governmental action. LGBT politics has aspired to acceptance, but it has not, for the most part, wanted to erase differences. Gay culture, as it has come to celebrate itself, is not to be found in Obergefell. People might go to a gay bar (or to a singles bar, an institution modeled on the gay bar) with a faint hope of finding a love that endures past the grave, but it is usually for the nearer promise that, sometime before last call, people get lucky. Here is the Supreme Court. Who would you go to looking for relationship advice? And--here I speculate, but with some confidence--there are no adepts of the gloryhole in this photo.
Secretary Clinton, too, has taken to invoking love out on the campaign trail. When she graduated from Wellesley, she was a featured speaker at commencement. There she spoke of her generation, of its discontent, of its yearning for 'a mode of living more immediate, more ecstatic, more penetrating.'
How'd that work out? For her husband, the jackpot! For her, if she's ever having a good time, it doesn't show.
The John Lewis tweet cited above,'Hate is too heavy a burden to bear,' continues: 'Love is the better way.' But love that won't bear a burden isn't meant, isn't love. Then what is this love of which he speaks? This is a very special love. It's not a burning, it's not bliss, it doesn't move the sun and other stars. It's tribalism, contented with itself, it's every good thing, it's that pleasantness in the mirror, it's just us.
Still, the Attorney General has recommended this love as her counter to terrorism.
Auden came to regret his most celebrated line, 'We must love one another or die.' There's no or about it. 'And die' was the true thing, and it would have been better poetry.You must choose, it's been said, and you must. Just, it mustn't be any of the given choices.
______________________________________________________________________
* If you struggled with trig in high school, it's a comfort to know that your leader is familiar with the calculus. He never studied it, mind, ttps://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/remarks-president-innovation-and-sustainable-growth-hudson-valley-community-college, but he certainly knows that, as a marker of cultural belonging, it sounds good in public speaking.
**This may not be the non-sequitur it looks like. According to the New Yorker, he once told his political director, in 2008, 'I think that I'm a better speechwriter than my speechwriters. I know more about policies on any particular issue than my policy directors. And I'll tell you right now that I'm going to think that I'm a better political director than my political director.' On at least one occasion, he has said, 'When the chips are down, I have Israel's back.' It stands to reason that he would consider himself a better Prime Minister of Israel than the Prime Minister of Israel.
The press has often spoken of Barack Obama as 'the adult in the room,' 'the smartest guy in the room.'
There is some photographic evidence that, frighteningly, he often is.
*** Submission to a violent death demonstrates repentance. The story is told of Muhammad and the woman taken in adultery, The Prophet of Islam told the crowd...no, different story. He told her that while she certainly must die by stoning, she could put it off. Dr. Sekaleshfar is a learned man.
****Identity politics is at the heart of today's Democratic Party, to the extent that its Promised Land often seems to be 1990's Yugoslavia. Before the current vogue for Hate, there was a fixation on 'hate speech,' which was the special target of identity politics. It was barely speech at all, and might be prohibited, prosecuted, shouted down, even physically attacked. Since this 'speech' wasn't really speech, it needn't even be spoken. Just Hate. This is our stop, looks like.
In the 1960's, the apartheid régime designated Japanese as 'honorary whites.' Understood: South Africa needed the investment money. The canons of our identity politics are not so easily mastered. When the non-white George Zimmerman shot someone in Sanford, FL, he was made an honorary white by, among others, the President and his Justice Department. In nearby Orlando, a white man killed 50 people at the Latin Night of a club. Presumably, more than a few of the victims were non-white. If anyone, at all, has commented on the fact, I've missed it.






No comments:
Post a Comment